The Third Thing
by I.M. Belle
James Madison did not trust government. He trusted structure.
That distinction matters. The compound republic he described in Federalist No. 39 was not built on the assumption that the people placed in positions of power would be wise or virtuous or restrained. It was built on the assumption that they would not be. That power would seek its own expansion. That faction would pursue its own interests. That no single person, no single party, no single ideology, could be trusted with unchecked authority.
So, he built the checks into the architecture itself. Federal power is constrained by national power. National power constrained by federal power. Each layer is accountable to someone and each layer is checked by someone else. Not because the system was elegant but rather the alternative would be tyranny.
What Madison could not have anticipated was the moment when every layer stopped checking and started serving. The same master. At the same time.
———
Madison’s analysis in No. 39 works through five questions about the Constitution’s character. How was it ratified? How is the House constituted? The Senate? The executive? And how does the government’s authority reach individuals?
Each question produced a different answer. Ratification was federal. The House was national. The Senate was federal. The executive was compound. The government’s operation on individuals was national. No single principle dominated. Every element of the design was in tension with every other element. Not but accident but rather on purpose.
“The proposed Constitution is, in strictness, neither a national nor a federal Constitution, but a composition of both.”
— James Madison, Federalist No. 39
The tension was the point. National power without federal structure was tyranny. Federal structure without national reach was impotence. The compound character of the republic was the answer to the central problem of self-governance: how do you create a government strong enough to function without making it powerful enough to dominate?
You build accountability into every layer. And then you depend on the people placed in positions of responsibility to exercise it.
———
Madison assumed the administrative function of government would grow. The first Congress created the Department of State, the Department of War, the Department of the Treasury. Hamilton ran Treasury with enormous administrative power. Jefferson ran State. The Secretary of State cannot personally process every passport request. The Attorney General cannot personally prosecute every case. The Secretary of the Treasury cannot personally audit every return.
Administrative function is not the enemy of the compound republic. It is how the compound republic operates on scale. Career civil servants following established law and procedure, answerable to agency heads, who are answerable to elected officials, who are answerable to voters. The chain of accountability running from the citizens all the way back to the Constitution.
That chain is what Madison trusted. Not the people in it. The chain itself.
———
In modern times, however, the chain is being cut.
The chain is not being cut by career civil servants. The people who have spent their professional lives following established law and procedure are not the problem — many of them are being fired for doing exactly that. The break is at the top. Elected officials, constitutionally responsible for guiding the administrative state, have abdicated that responsibility entirely. They have decided the agencies exist not to serve the public but to serve the ideology. They have replaced people who follow the law with people who follow the leader.
Consider the Department of Justice. Its entire constitutional purpose rests on a single premise: that the law applies equally, regardless of who holds power. The attorney general is the people’s lawyer. Not the president’s lawyer. Not the party’s lawyer. The people’s lawyer. Career prosecutors follow the evidence. They do not follow instructions about which cases to open and which to close based on the political convenience of the administration in power.
When career attorneys, who follow established law and procedure, are removed and replaced with loyalists whose qualification is personal fealty rather than legal expertise, DOJ does not stop being an administrative body. It stops being an accountable one. The form remains. The function has been captured.
And it is not only DOJ. It is visible at every layer of the compound republic simultaneously.
———
State attorneys general filing lawsuits not to enforce the law but to advance an ideology. State courts issuing rulings that align with the preferences of judges appointed specifically because they would sacrifice the law for personal beliefs. State agencies implementing policies that have no statutory basis because the legislature either could not or would not pass them through the proper process. Local officials decide which laws they will and will not enforce based on personal conviction rather than legal obligation.
At the federal level, agencies citing authority they do not have. Guidance documents enforced as law. Internal memoranda rescinding established policy without rulemaking oversight, without public notice, without legislative authorization. Career staff who object are consistently shown the door. Their replacements are told that the law means whatever ideology requires it to mean today.
And when citizens ask for legal justification, they are told to trust the officials. When courts push back, the officials question the courts’ legitimacy. When career staff follow the law instead of the instruction, they are called disloyal or removed. The question has shifted from “does this follow the law” to “does this serve the agenda of a few.”
Madison built every layer of the compound republic to check every other layer. That system fails when all the layers are captured by the same faction at the same time.
———
This is the third thing.
Not federal power. Not national power. The captured institution. The administrative body that has slipped its constitutional leash. Power that still wears the clothing of legitimate government while answering none of its accountability requirements. Power that fires anyone who reminds it what those requirements are.
Madison described two things. Power that is federal and power that is national. Each with its own accountability. Each with its own limits. Each answerable to someone.
The third thing answers to no one. And it tells us, with increasing confidence, that this is the point.
———
Madison’s answer to the problem of faction capturing government was the people themselves. Not any single election. Not any single institution. The people, continuously engaged, continuously informed, continuously demanding accountability from every layer of the republic they created and sustain.
That is still the answer. It has always been the only answer.
Not just at the federal level but wherever it is found…
Remember: Three in ten Americans of voting age cast a ballot for the current administration. Seven in ten did not. Some chose differently. Many chose not to choose at all. By any measure, the force dismantling the compound republic was not chosen by the people they claim to represent. Madison built a government for all of them. Not just the three.
The goal is not nostalgia. Remember the grass is truly greener on the other side and the past is always golden. Madison’s republic had its own profound failures, and this publication will not pretend otherwise. The goal is accountability to the standard the founders actually set. Not the standard they failed to live up to. The standard they described, in precise language, for precisely this purpose.
The Constitution does not care about your intentions.
It cares about your architecture.
Madison described a compound republic. Federal in some respects. National in others. Every layer accountable to someone.
He did not describe the third thing. We built it anyway. It is past time to name it for what it is.
I.M. Belle is a student of Jefferson, armed with Hamilton, and grounded in Madison — a Southern daughter writing at the end of her grace.
Read the original Federalist No. 39 by James Madison (1788): https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed39.asp
© 2026 I.M. Belle Media Ventures / U&Me Collections, Inc. All rights reserved.
___________________________________________________________________________
I write to make you think, not to tell you what to think. Subscribe free. If you believe that still matters, consider supporting the work with a donation.